A
Malaysian state government searched for a new site for a Hindu temple, bowing to
pressure from Muslim residents who staged a gruesome protest against its planned
construction that triggered debate about religious intolerance.
Authorities in central Selangor state tried to reach a compromise in talks with
residents of the Muslim-majority neighborhood in the state capital, Shah Alam,
where the temple was to be built. The meeting descended into chaos when
protesters shouted insults at Selangor Chief Minister Abdul Khalid Ibrahim and
other lawmakers, according to a video of the meeting posted on Malaysiakini, an
independent news Web site.
The protesters insist the temple would be too close to their homes and could
generate excessive noise and traffic, which would disrupt their concentration
during Muslim prayers they ludicrously claimed.
Cow Head Protest
Based on
article
from
prachatai.com
The Centre for Independent Journalism (CIJ) has criticised the Malaysian
Communication and Multimedia Commission (MCMC) over its request to online news
portal, Malaysiakini to take down videos related to a controversial protest
against the relocation of a temple in Shah Alam, close to the capital city of
Kuala Lumpur.
CIJ executive director Gayathry Venkiteswaran said the request was unwarranted
as it is an attempt by the government body to silence the messenger, in this
case the media, from reporting news.
She was referring to the letter sent to Malaysiakini by the MCMC requesting it
to remove two videos from its website. One of the videos was a footage from the
protest where a group of residents, mainly Malay Muslim dragged a severed cow
head to the premise of the state government office to protest the relocation of
a Hindu temple to their residential area on 28 August. Cows are generally
regarded with respect by most Hindu devotees.
Despite the action, there was no immediate police investigation into the
protest, which civil society groups condemned as legitimising violence and
hatred. In the last week, the Home Minister has come out in defense of the
protestors and even described them as victims in the issue. The Prime Minister
has come out more strongly against the actions of the protestors and the
authorities have promised to investigate the matter. The Home Minister's
statement was made in an environment where activists, critics and opposition
political parties have very little space for expression as the media is
overwhelmingly controlled by the ruling government and where their public
demonstrations have been met with heavy-handed tactics by the state.
Update: Cow
Head Protestors charged with sedition
11th September 2009. Based on
article
from
news.bbc.co.uk
Six Malaysian Muslims have been charged with sedition for parading the severed
head of a cow through the streets of Shah Alam in Selangor state last month. The
men were protesting against the building of a Hindu temple near a mosque in the
area. Some of the demonstrators stamped and spat on the cow's head.
The case has stoked tensions between Malaysia's Muslim majority and the Indian,
mainly Hindu, minority to whom cows are considered sacred.
Twelve of the protesters were charged with illegal assembly, which could see
them fined and jailed for up to a year.
Six were also charged with sedition - for promoting hostility between different
groups - and could face an additional three years in jail.
Defence lawyer Salehuddin Saidin said his clients were carrying the cow head to
illustrate the state government's stupidity - and did not intend to offend local
Hindus: For Malays, the cow symbolises stupidity, not an insult to any other
religion, Salehuddin claimed.
The authorities in Selangor have now found an alternative site for the Hindu
temple, further away from the mosque.
Update:
Reporters without Borders supports
malaysiakini.com
25th September 2009. Based on
article
from
rsf.org
Reporters
Without Borders has pledged its backing to independent news website Malaysiakini
which has decided to resist an order to remove two news videos judged to be
offensive by the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission.
The commission told the website in a letter on 3 September that it
considered the two film clips offensive and intended to upset
people, and particularly the Indians. The penalty for refusing to
comply is a fine of 50,000 ringgit (14,325 dollars) and one year in
prison.
The website www.malaysiakini.com had posted two video clips
accessible only to subscribers to the site, the first on 28 August
showing demonstrations by Malay Muslims against the building of a Hindu
temple in their neighbourhood, in which they spat on and trampled the
bloodied head of a cow, an animal sacred to Hindus. The second, on 2
September 2009, featured interior minister, Datuk Seri Hishamuddin Tun
Hussein, speaking at a press conference at which he urged demonstrators
not to use violence, while defending their right to protest.
But in a change of stance, on 3 September, the minister ordered
proceedings against the demonstrators. The removal order was made under
the Communications and Multimedia Act of 1988 banning all content
that is indecent, obscene, false, threatening or offensive with the
intention or harming, abusing, threatening or harassing a third party
.
The Malaysiakini website is right to resist the censorship the
government is trying to impose on it. The authorities should understand
that it is footage that shows something that happened, which may indeed
be embarrassing for some authorities but does not constitute an offence
, the worldwide press freedom organisation said.